UAE: Person fined Dh40,000 for insult in messaging app group; phone confiscated
The Al Ain Civil, Commercial and Administrative Claims Court in the UAE ordered a man to pay Dh20,000 in compensation for moral damages after he insulted another person in a messaging group. He had previously been fined Dh20,000 in a criminal case over the same incident. The criminal ruling also ordered the permanent closure of his messaging account and the confiscation of his seized mobile phone.
The case arose after the man used insulting language against another person in a messaging app group in the presence of several people. The victim said the remarks damaged his reputation and dignity and caused both material and moral harm.
Following the criminal conviction, the victim filed a civil lawsuit seeking Dh55,000 in compensation for material and moral damages. He also asked the court to order the defendant to pay legal costs and lawyers’ fees.
During the proceedings, the defendant’s lawyer challenged the Al Ain court’s territorial jurisdiction, arguing that his client lived and worked in another emirate and that the court was therefore not authorised to hear the case. He also claimed that the plaintiff had abused his right to bring legal action and called for the compensation claim to be dismissed.
However, the court rejected the jurisdictional challenge, explaining that in compensation claims arising from insults made through information technology, jurisdiction is not limited to the defendant’s place of residence. A court in the jurisdiction where the harm occurred may also hear the case.
The court said the evidence showed that the alleged harm had occurred within Al Ain’s jurisdiction and that the Al Ain court was therefore competent to consider the case.
Citing the final judgment in the criminal case, the court also said the insult and the defendant’s responsibility for it had already been established. The civil court could not reconsider or reject those findings and was required only to determine compensation proportionate to the harm caused.
In assessing the moral damages, the court said using insulting language in the presence of others was unlawful, harmed a person’s reputation and dignity, and caused emotional distress and psychological harm. It therefore found the defendant civilly liable for the moral damages.
However, the court rejected the claim for material damages, saying the plaintiff had provided no evidence of financial loss or loss of income or benefits resulting from the incident.
Taking into account the nature of the insulting remarks, the circumstances of the incident, how the offence was committed and its impact on the plaintiff’s reputation, the court awarded Dh20,000 as appropriate compensation for moral damages and rejected the claim for any additional amount.
The defendant was therefore ordered to pay Dh20,000 in compensation to the victim in addition to the Dh20,000 fine imposed in the criminal case. The two payments have different legal purposes: the fine is a criminal penalty, while the compensation is intended to redress the harm suffered by the victim.